Mid-Season Evaluations for MLB Teams
As June arrives, we gain better insight into the identities of various teams and the changes they’ve undergone since last season.
For several franchises, the conclusion is straightforward: they are performing better, as indicated by their records.
However, the term “better” holds different meanings for each team. With a lengthy season still ahead, maintaining success over the next four months is not assured.
Given this context, let’s assess the seven teams that have shown the most significant improvements in winning percentage since last year, examining their key advancements and the challenges they still face as the season progresses.
1. Detroit Tigers: +.125
2024 record: 86-76 (.531)
2025 record: 40-21 (.656)
Notable Improvement: After a surprising late-season push to the postseason in 2024, the Tigers’ pitching has continued to excel in 2025. The team currently boasts the American League’s best record, potentially leading to a franchise-record 106 wins, largely due to improved offensive performance despite retaining much of last year’s roster.
Question Ahead: Can their unexpected batting success continue? Several returning players have significantly improved their performance compared to 2024, raising concerns about the sustainability of this growth.
2. Chicago Cubs: +.115
2024 record: 83-79 (.512)
2025 record: 37-22 (.627)
Notable Improvement: The Cubs are positioned to surpass 100 wins, fueled by an impressive offense leading MLB with an average of 5.78 runs per game, driven by substantial contributions from standout players.
Question Ahead: Is their starting pitching adequate? Despite a strong offense, concerns linger regarding pitching depth, especially with injuries impacting key players.
3. New York Mets: +.084
2024 record: 89-73 (.549)
2025 record: 38-22 (.633)
Notable Improvement: The Mets have solidified their contender status, aided by both their high-priced lineup and a surprising pitching staff, which has achieved impressive results despite injuries.
Question Ahead: Can their starting pitchers maintain endurance through the season? Concerns are rising about the starters’ ability to last, particularly given past injury histories.
4. Los Angeles Angels: +.069
2024 record: 63-99 (.389)
2025 record: 27-32 (.458)
Notable Improvement: The Angels, while still below .500, have shown progress mainly due to a more powerful lineup, standing out with four players hitting double-digit home runs.
Question Ahead: Can they generate enough baserunners to capitalize on their home runs? Their overall offensive performance remains below average, undermining their power-hitting success.
5. Toronto Blue Jays: +.068
2024 record: 74-88 (.457)
2025 record: 31-28 (.525)
Notable Improvement: The Blue Jays are witnessing a turnaround with a notable uptick in their ability to secure late-game leads, largely due to a rejuvenated bullpen.
Question Ahead: Are they genuinely improved compared to 2024? Their performance may not be sustainable as they have been outscored overall this season.
6. San Francisco Giants: +.056
2024 record: 80-82 (.494)
2025 record: 33-27 (.550)
Notable Improvement: The Giants have surpassed expectations, maintaining competitive pace in the NL West, primarily thanks to a strong pitching staff.
Question Ahead: Are their offensive struggles indicative of future performances? Recent dips in offensive output raise concerns about reliance on robust pitching moving forward.
7. St. Louis Cardinals: +.047
2024 record: 83-79 (.512)
2025 record: 33-26 (.559)
Notable Improvement: Initially seen as a transitional year, the Cardinals have turned things around with a strong recent performance, aided by a resilient rotation.
Question Ahead: Is their success sustainable? There are signs that their current level of play may not accurately reflect their true capabilities, raising concerns about their long-term viability.
