By Tim Britton, Chad Jennings, and Levi Weaver
Each week, we survey a group of baseball writers—both local and national—to rank the teams from first to last. Here are the combined outcomes.
As we approach the midpoint of the season, it’s a suitable moment to evaluate how each team is faring relative to our expectations for the 2025 season. Some franchises, like the Dodgers and Phillies, are more or less aligning with our preseason predictions. Others, such as the Tigers and Blue Jays, are exceeding our forecasts, while teams like the Braves and Diamondbacks are underperforming compared to what we had anticipated. Performance is not the only factor, as injuries and ownership decisions also influence outcomes. However, examining how each team has performed can provide insights beyond the initial conditions they faced.
Various circumstances can shift a team’s success throughout the season, so let’s analyze the current standings to understand why certain teams are performing better, worse, or just as well as expected and what this may indicate for their future.
Mets Rise to the Top
Record: 45-27
Last Power Ranking: 2
Preseason Power Ranking: 5
The Mets started the season strong, quickly establishing themselves among the top teams. By late April, they overtook the Dodgers for the top spot in our rankings, with standout performances from Pete Alonso and Francisco Lindor easing concerns about Juan Soto and the pitching staff. The NL East has not developed as a tight race as predicted; nevertheless, the Mets have solidified their position at the top, exceeding initial expectations. — Chad Jennings
Dodgers Maintain Strong Position
Record: 44-29
Last Power Ranking: T-3
Preseason Power Ranking: 1
Despite a hot start, the Dodgers have performed at a solid level but not as dominant as expected. They lead one of baseball’s strongest divisions, and projections still favor them to finish with one of the best records. The team has managed multiple injuries among their starters but remains a strong contender—if they can reintegrate their core players effectively. — Tim Britton
Surprising Performances in Detroit
Record: 46-27
Last Power Ranking: 1
Preseason Power Ranking: T-16
The Tigers have experienced an exceptional season, with players like Tarik Skubal and Spencer Torkelson delivering outstanding performances. Contributions from others such as Casey Mize and relievers have propelled the team’s success. However, they will face challenges ahead, particularly with the recent injury to closer Will Vest. — Levi Weaver
Yankees Find Their Place
Record: 42-29
Last Power Ranking: T-3
Preseason Power Ranking: 7
Despite starting the season with injuries to key players, the Yankees have become one of the top teams in the American League. The performances from stars like Aaron Judge and Max Fried have contributed significantly, allowing them to rise above early struggles and solidify their standing among the league’s best. — Chad Jennings
Other Teams to Watch
Record: 44-28
Last Power Ranking: 5
Preseason Power Ranking: 12
The emergence of Pete Crow-Armstrong has fueled the Cubs’ season, supported by strong performances from players like Carson Kelly and Kyle Tucker. As they prepare for a potential deep playoff run, their focus will be on maintaining momentum and addressing any roster adjustments needed before the trade deadline. — Levi Weaver
Preseason Favorites Underperforming
Record: 36-35
Last Power Ranking: 12
Preseason Power Ranking: 3
Both the Braves and Diamondbacks entered the season with high expectations but have struggled to meet them. Key players have been hindered by injuries or poor performance, causing these teams to fall short of their predicted success. They will need to regroup quickly if they wish to stay in contention. — Chad Jennings
