The committee responsible for evaluating the Avenir casino proposal has now heard from over 300 speakers who expressed various views on its impact on a section of Manhattan.
Recent Developments in the Casino Licensing Race
On Monday evening, Silverstein Properties presented its Avenir proposal at its second public hearing, marking a significant step in the quest for a downstate New York casino license. This meeting, the first of eight bids to reach this stage, took place at the Javits Center.
Public Hearing Insights
Approximately 200 speakers participated in the nearly five-hour hearing, which was conducted by the community advisory committee (CAC). The six-member CAC has completed its requirement of hosting two hearings but may opt for additional sessions before the September 30 deadline for a binding vote, which necessitates at least four members’ support for Avenir to be considered by state officials.
Community Reactions and Challenges
The hearing echoed themes from the first public session on August 27, albeit with about twice the number of speakers. The committee encouraged those who spoke previously not to address the audience again, but many reiterated their positions. While public support for the project has been voiced by unions, business groups, and community organizations, local residents closest to the site have predominantly expressed opposition.
The Avenir Project and Its Significance
Avenir, meaning “future” in French, is one of three proposals in Manhattan, situated at 41st Street and 11th Avenue. Silverstein is renowned as a residential property owner in the vicinity and as the lead redeveloper of the World Trade Center site. The company, having owned the Avenir site for years, argues that a casino is vital for anchoring a $7 billion mixed-use development.
Economic Implications and Community Focus
The CAC’s upcoming vote on Avenir will reflect the project’s public support level, with unions and trade groups backing it, alongside substantial job creation promises. Silverstein also aims to enhance the area by developing a 1,000-room Hyatt hotel and pledging 2,000 housing units, including approximately 500 affordable ones. This could potentially generate increased activity around the Javits Center, which lacks major hotels.
Diverse Perspectives within the Community
Opinions among local residents were divided, with supporters primarily living in Silverstein properties and dissenters from other nearby housing complexes, particularly Manhattan Plaza. Detractors, especially older residents, voiced concerns about the potential erosion of community safety and security brought about by a casino. Conversely, younger residents argued for economic advancement and opportunities within the bustling environment of Midtown Manhattan.
Looking Ahead
While community groups and organizations like Covenant House and Rethink Food have thrown their weight behind the Avenir project, residents remain skeptical. Despite fears expressed by some, many younger individuals see the potential for job creation and economic growth as essential. The discussion is ongoing, with the committee’s decision hanging in the balance.
