New First Baseman for the Padres
With Luis Arraez moving to San Francisco on a one-year contract, the Padres have officially confirmed a new player at first base for this season. According to Jeff Sanders from the San Diego Union-Tribune, Gavin Sheets is expected to take on this position.
Gavin Sheets’ Previous Performance
Sheets, 29, had a respectable debut with the team last season. In 145 games, he posted a batting line of .252/.317/.429 with a wRC+ of 111. However, his overall performance was hampered by poor defensive metrics in the outfield. Returning to first base—his original position in the White Sox minor league system, where he was blocked by Jose Abreu—might help him regain some defensive value and build upon his solid offensive showing from 2025.
Sheets’ Struggles Against Lefties
Although a defensive improvement from moving to first base would be beneficial, it won’t address Sheets’ significant platoon split from last season. He achieved a wRC+ of 119 against right-handed pitchers but only managed an 89 wRC+ against lefties. Most of his power came against righties, as he hit 17 of his 19 home runs in 2025 off right-handed pitchers. Adding a right-handed hitter as a complement to him would be wise, with potential options like Paul Goldschmidt, Ty France, and Rhys Hoskins still available.
Utilizing the DH Role
This new addition could also influence the designated hitter (DH) strategy, which has been affected by Sheets’ transition to first base. Offseason signing Sung-Mun Song and rookie Will Wagner might also take turns at DH. Song’s ability to play multiple infield positions allows the DH spot to be utilized for resting regulars like Manny Machado, who could have days at DH, while Song covers third base.
AJ Preller’s Future
With the need for strategic signings, A.J. Preller, president of baseball operations, has mentioned he is actively looking to secure players who will positively impact the roster. However, his contract status has also come under scrutiny. Preller expressed to reporters that not having an extension agreed upon before the last season of his contract is partly “on him.” Unlike earlier reports that suggested a soon-to-be deal, it now appears possible that he may enter the 2026 season without clarity on his future.
Conclusion
This puts Preller in a vulnerable position as there have been indications of tension between him and club CEO Erik Greupner. His future will be closely monitored, as he would be an attractive candidate for rival teams if the Padres decide to part ways with him. Since Preller took over in late 2014, the Padres have seen their most successful stretch of baseball, making the playoffs four times under his guidance.
