In anticipation of updating our Top 500 dynasty prospect list released last week, we thoroughly analyzed advanced Statcast data, scouting reports, and industry rankings. This last component is vital as it sheds light on the perceived value of specific players. Consequently, it enables us to strategically target players we are confident in, while being cautious with those we have doubts about.
Today, we will highlight 15 fantasy prospects that we believe are undervalued according to industry consensus—as much as significantly so—as we head into the 2026 season. We’ll explain our rationale behind these bold rankings and why these players stand out as great targets for acquisition before Opening Day.
Devin Fitz-Gerald, 2B/SS, Nationals
We previously discussed why Fitz-Gerald is a key target as we approach 2026. The infielder made his debut in the Arizona Complex League last spring and impressed, resulting in a promotion to Low-A Hickory after just one month. Unfortunately, a shoulder injury cut his season short, but when healthy, he displayed a solid combination of skills.
Kendall George, OF, Dodgers
As long as batting average and stolen bases count in fantasy leagues, profiles based on speed and contact will remain valuable. George is close in ranking to the Orioles’ Enrique Bradfield Jr. but offers similar skills at a more accessible price. His 2025 stats with High-A Great Lakes included a .295/.409/.370 line and 100 stolen bases. With an 80-grade tool, George leverages his exceptional speed and baserunning to pile up steals, although his power is limited.
Brock Wilken, 3B, Brewers
Few players have faced as much adversity as Wilken in the last two years. He missed most of 2024 due to a severe hit-by-pitch incident and subsequently sat out the latter half of 2025 due to a knee injury sustained during a celebration. Prior to the injury, he was performing at a high level, with a .226/.387/.489 line over 79 games despite facing tough conditions in the Southern League.
Jake Bennett, LHP, Red Sox
After the 2025 season, acquiring Bennett was relatively cheap, but a recent trade to the Red Sox and deeper analysis of his release traits has led to a surge in his dynasty value. Returning from Tommy John surgery, he posted a 2.27 ERA over 75.1 innings between High-A and Double-A, even though he didn’t have a high strikeout rate. His transition to a better pitching development program should enhance his prospects moving forward.
Brandon Clarke, LHP, Cardinals
Clarke’s stock rose significantly early last season when he displayed impressive velocity and pitch movement. However, blister issues led to command problems, and he was later traded to the Cardinals in a notable deal. Despite potential relief risks, the volatility surrounding Clarke presents a valuable buying opportunity for those seeking high-upside prospects.
