Turning Points in Salah’s Role
The 4-1 defeat to PSV at home likely prompted Arne Slot to reconsider Mohamed Salah’s position in the lineup, but a narrower loss to Chelsea at Stamford Bridge in October could have been the real catalyst. Chelsea’s Marc Cucurella noted how easily he moved into the box, underscoring a vulnerability that opponents have been quick to exploit against Liverpool.
Targeting Defensive Weaknesses
Cucurella explained to Sky Sports, “We know Salah is poised to counter-attack, which means teams can exploit the space,” adding that this tactic proved successful that day. This trend continued in the subsequent four Premier League defeats for Liverpool, where opponents primarily targeted the left wing, corresponding to Salah’s defensive side. Jamie Carragher’s commentary on Salah’s defensive contributions illustrates the issue at hand.
Decline in Defensive Contributions
Salah’s defensive strengths have never been his hallmark. Jurgen Klopp previously utilized Jordan Henderson to solidify Liverpool’s defensive framework. However, statistical trends indicate a significant drop in Salah’s defensive engagement following Klopp’s departure. The deal between Salah and Slot involved sacrificing some defensive responsibilities in exchange for increased offensive contributions.
Offensive Output Under Scrutiny
Salah claimed, “Now I don’t have to defend much,” suggesting a tactical shift that allowed him to focus on offense. Yet, his recent output—six non-penalty goals in his last 33 appearances—casts doubt on whether he’s fulfilling his end of the bargain. After the PSV match, Carragher remarked on Salah’s inability to challenge effectively, emphasizing the alarming gaps in defense that opponents have been exploiting.
Physical Decline and Tactical Adjustments
At 34, Salah’s physical decline is expected. His once-lethal speed and sprint numbers are down, raising questions about his ability to contribute defensively even if he wanted to. This decline explains Slot’s decision to drop a player whose defensive liabilities have become evident, as Salah rarely tracks back to his defensive position.
A Manager’s Dilemma
As Carragher pointed out, a manager facing defensive struggles is likely to remove the player who has been excused from defensive duties. This explains Salah’s absence as a substitute during critical moments of matches, like the 2-0 win at West Ham where defense was prioritized over scoring. Statistical comparisons further reveal Liverpool’s pressing intensity is heightened when Salah is absent from the pitch.
Future Implications for Salah
While Salah’s outspoken comments have caught media attention, the heart of the issue lies in his waning offensive contributions and growing defensive liabilities. Until he can return to the scoring prowess that solidified his legacy at the club, trust in him will continue to dwindle, making both his performance and behavior crucial for his future at Liverpool.
