Stuart Broad criticized England’s bowling performance, labeling it their “worst” in years and expressing the need for more from “generational talent” Harry Brook, as the team trails 0-2 in the Ashes series following two consecutive eight-wicket losses.
The bowling unit, which had shown promise during the Perth Test, struggled significantly during the first innings in Brisbane, delivering frequent short and wide deliveries. Broad expressed disappointment over the squad’s lack of “problem-solving” and communication on the field.
Brook, the vice-captain, has not found his rhythm, having made just 31, zero, and 15 after an initial fifty in the first Test. He fell to a reckless shot played against pink-ball expert Mitchell Starc as England began their twilight batting period.
England’s Bowling Lapses
On the final day of the third Test, Broad noted that England failed to put pressure on Australia’s lower-order batsmen, leading to a dispiriting six-wicket collapse. He described the day as one of the most discouraging he had witnessed, emphasizing that it’s vital for bowlers to have individual plans and not rely solely on captain Ben Stokes for guidance.
Broad further lamented that the entire team bowled short and wide on a pitch that should have been more advantageous, calling it the worst collective bowling effort since 2008. He questioned the selection strategy, suggesting that bowlers like Josh Tongue, known for hitting fuller lengths, should have been included instead of those who delivered similar back-of-a-length bowling.
Brook’s Dismissals
Despite averaging 55.05 in his Test career, Brook’s recent performances raise concerns, averaging only 24.50 in this series with several soft dismissals. Broad noted that great players adapt well to in-game situations, citing Kevin Pietersen’s early successes as a point of reference. He believes Brook needs to elevate his game to match expectations, especially in Australia.
Concerns Over Jamie Smith’s Performance
Broad also expressed frustration regarding wicketkeeper Jamie Smith’s debut with the pink ball occurring in an Ashes Test, believing it compromised Smith’s performance. Broad noted that Smith, who scored nought and four, was unprepared for the unique challenges of a pink-ball match, particularly facing fast bowlers like Starc under lights. He emphasized the importance of experience and training with the pink ball prior to crucial matches.
