Strong Reactions to Kennedy Family Depiction
The airing of the Kennedy family’s story—a narrative closely observed like royalty in America—has elicited intense responses. The initial images from Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette, featuring Paul Anthony Kelly and Sarah Pidgeon in the lead roles, attracted both attention and criticism following their release on Ryan Murphy Productions’ Instagram in June.
Initial Criticism and On-Set Realities
Fashion critics and Carolyn’s former hairstylist scrutinized Pidgeon’s hair and outfit choices, igniting discussions about her depiction of the ’90s style icon. The challenges of filming, compounded by paparazzi presence, sparked heightened scrutiny. Executive producer Brad Simpson noted the similarities to Carolyn Bessette’s experiences with sudden fame and criticism.
Adapting to Backlash
Instead of deterring the creative team, the backlash served as a motivational catalyst. Series creator Connor Hines expressed that he was enthusiastic about audience investment in the project.
Honoring a Tragic Love Story
Love Story is inspired by Elizabeth Beller’s biography and explores the romance between John and Carolyn, culminating in the tragic 1999 plane crash near Martha’s Vineyard that also took Carolyn’s sister Lauren Bessette. The show aims to depict this love story with respect for their memories.
Mixed Reactions from the Kennedy Family
Jack Schlossberg, JFK’s grandson, openly criticized the series, calling it “grotesque” for exploiting his uncle’s life. Nevertheless, the production team has maintained their commitment to integrity and hopes the Kennedy family will appreciate the respectful portrayal.
Acting and Casting Decisions
In discussions about the casting process for the leading roles, Hines indicated that Pidgeon quickly stood out as the ideal Carolyn, while the search for John involved auditioning over 1,000 candidates. The production sought actors who resembled their characters closely, maintaining a fresh perspective for audiences.
Upcoming Premiere and Final Thoughts
Love Story is slated to premiere on February 12 at 6 PM PT/9 PM ET on FX/Hulu, starting with three episodes, followed by weekly releases of the nine-episode series.
