The significance of the 2025 draft class for the 49ers has been emphasized repeatedly. San Francisco must gain substantial contributions from several members of its 11-player class to enhance their chances for a Super Bowl run, especially after last year’s disappointing 6-11 record.
To achieve both near-term goals and ensure the roster’s long-term viability, it is essential for the 49ers to see various rookies excel during a year where a favorable schedule could support their efforts.
So, how many of the 49ers’ rookies are likely to step up and make a significant impact as starters in 2025?
As training camp approaches, let’s delve into that question.
Certainties
Two players seem assured of starting roles from day one. Mykel Williams, the 11th overall pick, is expected to start at defensive end alongside Nick Bosa during base downs, while also shifting inside for passing situations.
Second-round draft pick Alfred Collins recently signed his rookie contract and is also seen as a guaranteed starter due to the lack of veteran options. The team hopes he will strengthen their interior run defense and tap into his potential as a pass rusher.
Camp Competitors
Third-round picks Nick Martin and Upton Stout will be vying for starting positions in camp.
Martin is a strong contender for a starter role. Even if he doesn’t secure the WILL linebacker position battling Dee Winters, he is still likely to be the starting SAM linebacker, having consistently overperformed his size at Oklahoma State. He aims for a three-down role at WILL rather than a limited position at SAM.
Stout is competing with Tre Brown for the third cornerback spot. After a strong showing in offseason practices, Stout hopes to convince the coaching staff to utilize him as their nickel corner, with Deommodore Lenoir shifting back to a full-time outside role.
Possible Opportunities
In the fourth round, the 49ers added receiver Jordan Watkins from Ole Miss.
Rookie receivers often struggle for playing time under Kyle Shanahan, and Watkins faces stiff competition on the depth chart.
However, with uncertainties surrounding Brandon Aiyuk’s return, potential trades involving Jauan Jennings, injuries to Ricky Pearsall, and discipline issues facing Demarcus Robinson, there remains a slim chance for Watkins to start in Week 1.
Long Shots
Fifth-round pick Marques Sigle’s chances of starting improved following George Odum’s release, elevating him on the safety depth chart. Nevertheless, with Malik Mustapha unlikely to be ready for the season opener, Ji’Ayir Brown and Jason Pinnock are more likely to start.
Running back Jordan James is expected to begin the season as the 49ers’ third running back, but his potential for a more significant role cannot be disregarded due to the injury histories of Christian McCaffrey and Isaac Guerendo.
