The last time we observed the Chicago White Sox, they were concluding a dismal 2024 season, which resulted in a record-breaking 121 losses. Since that time, they have traded their top performer, ace Garrett Crochet, and have not added significant talent in free agency.
This raises questions about whether the White Sox will continue to struggle in 2025, which veterans might be traded away this season, and if any other team in Major League Baseball might finish with a worse record. ESPN MLB analysts Buster Olney, Jesse Rogers, and David Schoenfield share their insights.
Comparison of the White Sox Roster from Last Season to This Season
Olney: The White Sox are transitioning past their initial rebuilding phase, having traded away many veterans from the 2024 roster, such as Eloy Jimenez and Michael Kopech, alongside the release of free agents like Yoan Moncada. Their current roster is largely filled with young, inexperienced players. The White Sox are likely open to trading their remaining veterans, like Luis Robert Jr., who may not be part of the long-term plan. After hitting rock bottom last year, the team is poised for what will likely be a lengthy recovery.
Rogers: This year’s team is younger and inexperienced, particularly in the pitching lineup, with 25-year-old Sean Burke starting on Opening Day. Alongside Jonathan Cannon (24), Davis Martin, and injured Drew Thorpe, the team lacks recognizable names apart from veteran Martin Perez.
Forecasting the White Sox’s Win Record for the Season
Olney: Generally, trading a top starting pitcher would influence the team’s win-loss record. However, Crochet’s pitching last year yielded a poor 9-23 record for the White Sox. Competing against improved teams in their division will also pose challenges. A new beginning under manager Will Venable may uplift the team’s culture, so I anticipate a slight increase in wins, projecting them at 45-117.
Rogers: I predict a rough start for the White Sox, compounded by Benintendi’s hand injury and an underwhelming bullpen. However, they’re likely to perform better in the second half of the season with Montgomery’s anticipated debut and contributions from top prospects. By season’s end, I foresee a record of 54-108.
Best Player for the White Sox This Season
Olney: Undoubtedly, Robert will be the standout if he can maintain his health. His performance will be vital for Chicago, particularly concerning his trade value as the July 31 deadline approaches. Teams will be keen to acquire him based on his output this season.
Rogers: If Robert isn’t performing, it could indicate injury or other issues. He remains their most talented player, but Tauchman might also prove to be a consistent contributor. Prospects like Montgomery could shine in the near future, yet for now, Robert holds the top spot.
Projected Trade Candidates from the White Sox
Olney: Aside from Robert, players like Benintendi could attract interest if they rebound. If Robert excels, he may very well become the centerpiece of trade discussions.
Rogers: Robert will likely be on the moving block in July if he performs well.
Will the White Sox Finish as the Worst Team in Baseball Again?
Olney: It’s hard to see them avoiding the worst record again. The Miami Marlins, who are a step ahead in their rebuilding process, might manage to win a third of their games, while the White Sox may struggle to keep pace.
Rogers: The competition for the worst record is tight, but I predict the White Sox will finish last while still showing improvement with approximately 15 extra wins.
Schoenfield: I believe they will indeed finish at the bottom again. While the Marlins could challenge them, their stronger bullpen should secure them better results.
