It’s time for my second weekly mock draft for the New York Giants, now including selections into Round 4 since the team lacks a third-round pick this year.
At this early point—over two months before the 2026 NFL Draft—I’m not aiming for accuracy but rather exploring various possibilities for how the draft could unfold for the Giants.
This week, I’m selecting a different set of three players compared to last week’s mock draft.
Round 1 (No. 5) — Carnell Tate, WR, Ohio State
I opted for a conventional choice this time. Tate was selected in 16 out of 46 recent mock drafts (34.8%) according to our latest mock draft tracker.
The Giants must enhance their arsenal for second-year quarterback Jaxson Dart. With Malik Nabers already added, the team needs a secondary receiver, like Tate, to bolster their offensive capabilities.
Lance Zierlein of NFL Media compares Tate to Chris Olave, who has achieved three 1,000-yard seasons with the New Orleans Saints. He highlights Tate’s potential to emerge as a significant player early in his career.
Other choices considered: Caleb Downs, S, Ohio State
Round 2 (No. 37) — Emmanuel McNeil-Warren, S, Toledo
Although I didn’t select Caleb Downs earlier, the idea of adding a versatile safety is still appealing for Dennard Wilson’s defense. NFL Network’s Daniel Jeremiah has both McNeil-Warren and Dillon Thieneman in his top 25 prospects.
Here, I’m choosing McNeil-Warren, a 6-foot-1⅝, 202-pound safety from Toledo, though it’s a close call between him and Thieneman.
With good range and burst, McNeil-Warren showcases the ability to make plays across the field. His motor is impressive, highlighting his toughness. He has the potential to become a starting safety, demonstrating strong play-making ability early in his career.
Others considered: Caleb Banks, DL, Florida; Dillon Thieneman, S, Oregon; Colton Hood, CB, Tennessee; among others.
Round 4 (No. 105) — Keylan Rutledge, G, Georgia Tech
With uncertainties surrounding free agency, it’s essential to prioritize the interior linemen soon.
Rutledge stands at 6-3⅜ and weighs 316 pounds. His agility and explosiveness on run plays stand out, coupled with a strong physical presence.
He has the potential to be a starting right guard, showcasing power and agility in varying blocking schemes. While his pass-blocking technique needs polishing, his athleticism is promising.
Others considered: Emmett Johnson, RB, Nebraska; Max Klate, TE, Ohio State; among others.
