If Song Sung Blue, which had its World Premiere as the Closing Night film of AFI Fest, weren’t based on a true story, it’s unlikely anyone would have the audacity to create it. The remarkable fortunes and heart-wrenching misfortunes of a Milwaukee tribute band, Lightning And Thunder, may take some creative liberties (as all true stories do), but the astonishing realities they face make it easy to see why director Craig Brewer (Hustle & Flow) found this story compelling enough for a film.
Derived from Greg Koh’s 2008 documentary, the narrative focuses on two aspiring musicians who find themselves relegated to performing as vocal impersonators in local bars while juggling their day jobs. Mike Sardina (Hugh Jackman), a divorced Vietnam veteran and recovering alcoholic, clings to his musical aspirations. Claire Stengl (Kate Hudson), a single mother of two working as a hairdresser, channels her passion through her impersonation of Patsy Cline. When Claire encourages a collaboration, they form a Neil Diamond tribute band, opting for the stage names Lightning and Thunder.
To Mike’s surprise, he discovers he has a talent for emulating Diamond (Jackman’s comedic performance in his underwear seals the deal), and their chemistry—both onstage and off—blooms, leading to intimate performances and rising popularity in Milwaukee. They quickly assemble a backing band that features Mark Shurilla (Michael Imperioli), a talented Buddy Holly impersonator, and soon attract a manager, Tom D’Amato (a fitting Jim Belushi). Their Diamond tribute act reaches local acclaim, even opening for Pearl Jam during their Wisconsin shows, where Mike has a memorable duet with Eddie Vedder (John Beckwith) on “Forever In Blue Jeans.” Everything appears to be shaping up for their American dream until tragedy strikes. The film’s vibrant tone shifts as the love story unfolds, testing Claire’s optimistic spirit.
Brewer manages to maintain the delicate balance of this musical comedy/drama, prompting viewers to ponder the authenticity of the events. Ultimately, Song Sung Blue transcends just being a tribute to Neil Diamond; it’s an homage to the resilience of the characters at its heart. The film shines thanks to the endearing performances of its stars. Jackman, with his Diamond-style hair, skillfully embodies the complexities of a man who finds solace in music. His vocals are impressive, seamlessly portraying an iconic artist. Hudson gives a remarkable performance in her finest role since her Oscar-nominated portrayal of Penny Lane in Almost Famous, blending musical talent with emotional depth.
Song Sung Blue serves as a fitting title, reflecting the unpredictable nature of life while telling the story of two earnest souls discovering love and shared joy in music. This story isn’t just a mere imitation; it captures the richness of life, weaving genuine emotion into the narrative.
The film, produced by Brewer, John Davis, and John Fox, features an ensemble cast including Hugh Jackman, Kate Hudson, Jim Belushi, Michael Imperioli, and others, delivering a robust cinematic experience.
Title: Song Sung Blue
Festival: AFI Fest
Distributor: Focus Features
Release Date: December 25, 2025
Director/Screenplay: Craig Brewer
Cast: Hugh Jackman, Kate Hudson, Jim Belushi, Michael Imperioli, Ella Anderson, King Princess, Mustafa Shakir, Hudson Hensley, Fisher Stevens
Rating: PG13
Running Time: 2 hours and 11 Minutes
