epa11984157 Alessandro Buongiorno of Italy (R) gestures during the UEFA Nations League quarterfinal, 2nd leg match between Germany and Italy in Dortmund, Germany, 23 March 2025. EPA-EFE/FRIEDEMANN VOGEL
Following one of the most dramatic matches in Azzurri history, Italy faced a narrow defeat against Germany over two legs. Giancarlo Rinaldi attempts to unpack what transpired in Milan and Dortmund.
At halftime in Germany, I was contemplating Italy’s exit from the tournament. They appeared so outmatched that it seemed unlikely they could compete with elite teams anytime soon. However, their spirited second-half performance suggested a glimpse of potential, though it came too late to affect the outcome, leaving many, including myself, puzzled. Was the true Italy the one struggling defensively, or the team that, without VAR interference, might have had a chance to equalize? Here are some thoughts on the two matches.
Corner Calamities
Set-piece issues have consistently plagued this squad, culminating in the embarrassing second goal conceded in Germany. Goalkeeper Gigio Donnarumma’s blunder allowed Jamal Musiala to score into an open net. The team appeared jittery and disorganized at corners and free kicks, leading to a foreseeable struggle against any opponent. Opposing teams now know that a good delivery can unravel a defense that was once the envy of many.
Dimarco’s Absence
While many players’ reputations may have risen due to their absence, the loss of the Inter wing-back was especially significant. No single player could have neutralized the aggressive German side, but Dimarco’s attacking prowess could have alleviated some pressure on Italy and created additional issues for Germany.
Signs of Sandro
Amid the disappointment, the performance of Sandro Tonali offered some hope. His goal in the first leg led fans to fantasize about hosting the Nations League semi-finals. Despite struggling in the second match’s first half, his presence signaled that Italy has a quality box-to-box midfielder returning to form.
Cool Kean
Fiorentina’s striker had limited opportunities throughout the two games but displayed poise when chances arose. This confirmed his best goal-scoring season yet and continued his impressive form with the national team, even as he faced a robust German defense that generally neutralized his contributions.
Variable VAR
The interpretation of what constitutes a clear and obvious error can vary. After a dominant first half for Germany, Italy found renewed hope as they began to play better. Moise Kean nearly completed a hat-trick, only for an intervention by officials to disallow the goal. While a touch by Nico Schlotterbeck on Giovanni Di Lorenzo was almost imperceptible, it was enough for the referee to reconsider his call, leaving Italian fans questioning the adequacy of that decision.
