Knicks’ Coaching Search: A Complicated Situation

INDIANAPOLIS — The decision to fire Tom Thibodeau was anticipated.

For those confused about the New York Knicks’ coaching search strategies, particularly since they lacked a clear successor when they dismissed their most successful coach of recent years on June 3, there’s more insight to uncover. Owner James Dolan and the organization had already moved on from Thibodeau long before he helped them reach their first Eastern Conference finals since 2000. The tumultuous search that followed, including multiple attempts to get permission to speak with other coaches, has been unprecedented in the NBA.

As Game 3 of the NBA Finals began at Gainbridge Fieldhouse, chats about the Knicks’ coaching dilemma circulated among front office personnel. Coaches like Billy Donovan from Chicago, Ime Udoka from Houston, Chris Finch from Minnesota, Quin Snyder from Atlanta, and Jason Kidd from Dallas have made an appearance on the Knicks’ wish list. However, there are indications that Kidd is not looking to leave the Mavericks.

For further context, I sought out potential coaches the Knicks might have tried to engage. While no new candidates emerged, reports indicate they did not seek permission from notable names such as Rick Carlisle, Steve Kerr, Doc Rivers, Ty Lue, or JJ Redick. The coaches they did pursue are respected, but the Knicks’ bold approach to this search reveals much about the organization’s sentiments regarding Thibodeau, even as they are still financially obligated to him.

Whispers about Thibodeau’s job security surfaced before the playoffs, prompting inquiries about his future. While some close to him believed the Knicks wouldn’t make such a drastic move, others within the organization insisted everything was fine, especially after upending the defending champion Celtics in the playoffs. Unlike other coaches who seemed secure in their positions during critical playoff moments, Thibodeau’s situation was precarious, culminating in his surprising firing after falling to Indiana.

Interestingly, despite the ongoing chaotic search, reports suggest the Knicks are keen on two former coaches: Mike Brown, who previously coached the Sacramento Kings, and Taylor Jenkins, formerly of the Memphis Grizzlies. As the Knicks finalize their list of potential candidates, Brown stands out due to his long-standing relationship with Knicks executive William Wesley, which may give him an edge.

Brown, who had a strong interview with the Knicks in 2020 before Thibodeau was hired, later showcased his coaching skills with the Kings before parting ways with them. Jenkins, who led the Grizzlies to their highest win total in franchise history, was recently let go despite a solid reputation. Meanwhile, the Pacers, who recently eliminated the Knicks in the playoffs, are now competing for an NBA championship, highlighting that the Knicks may not be as distant from success as they believe.