While the NFL has embraced analytics, impatient owners and anxious front offices still struggle to “trust the process.” In the past 15 months, 13 of the 32 head coach positions have become vacant, with teams like the Raiders and Patriots hiring new coaches twice. Despite the introduction of modern methodologies and a network of connections—like those involving Sean McVay or Kyle Shanahan—the primary constant is that winning is essential. Without victories, no lineage or coaching expertise can save you.
As I mention annually, various factors like players, owners, injuries, and pure luck can impact outcomes as much as coaching prowess. Thus, while this article provides rankings, I prefer to think of it as a snapshot of where each of the league’s 32 coaches stands currently, along with insights into their journeys and future directions. You can find last year’s list here. This year’s rankings can be accessed here.
Who is the best coach in the NFL?
1. Andy Reid, Chiefs
Career Record: 273-146-1 (.651)
With The Chiefs Since: 2013
Last Year’s Ranking: 1
Andy Reid has pushed the offensive envelope, but how long can a team thrive on just scheme and quarterback brilliance? This theory faced scrutiny during the Super Bowl when it became clear that even Patrick Mahomes needs supportive elements like receiving depth and an effective running game. Reid’s success isn’t solely linked to Mahomes, but rather showcases his extensive coaching history and vision, with impressive stats predating Mahomes’ tenure. Even if Reid has imperfections, he closely stands as one of football’s best coaches currently.
2. Sean McVay, Rams
Career Record: 80-52 (.606)
With The Rams Since: 2017
Last Year’s Ranking: 2
Sean McVay has demonstrated his offensive genius often supported by great players like Aaron Donald. While he faced significant challenges in 2024, he secured his fourth division title and continues to have a strong influence from play-calling to player selection, securing impactful draft picks. While dealing with an aging quarterback like Matthew Stafford, he maintained composure and avoided panic, charting a path of sustained success that seems to point to potential future Hall of Fame accolades.
3. John Harbaugh, Ravens
Career Record: 172-104 (.623)
With The Ravens Since: 2008
Last Year’s Ranking: 3
John Harbaugh has seen several quarterbacks come and go, finally settling with Lamar Jackson from 2018 onward. Despite the strong competition in the AFC, Harbaugh consistently leads his team to the playoffs, becoming a pillar of coaching excellence through his analytical approach paired with traditional strategies. There are challenges from strong competition, yet his coaching prowess still shines bright, positioning the Ravens well for future successes.
4. Kyle Shanahan, 49ers
Career Record: 70-62 (.530)
With The 49ers Since: 2017
Last Year’s Ranking: 4
Kyle Shanahan’s volatile record showcases the dependence of his success on the health of key players. While he has faced challenges, he has also achieved remarkable feats with backups like Jimmy Garoppolo and Brock Purdy. His ability to create impactful offenses puts him in elite company, although the dependence on health adds a layer of uncertainty to his coaching narrative.
5. Nick Sirianni, Eagles
Career Record: 48-20 (.706)
With The Eagles Since: 2021
Last Year’s Ranking: 15
Nick Sirianni’s trajectory has been impressive, turning a struggling team into a perennial playoff contender. His adaptability, transitioning from a balanced approach to a more conventional strategy, has strengthened the Eagles under his leadership. Despite facing heavy scrutiny, Sirianni has navigated numerous challenges while rallying the team to playoff success, showcasing significant growth in just a few years.
