The significance of debate over wildcard selections in the Ryder Cup has evolved over the years.
Previously, U.S. captains only had two wildcard picks up until 2006, and there was usually a consensus on those choices.
This year, similar to 2021 and 2023, half of Keegan Bradley’s team will consist of wildcard selections.
With many players presenting strong cases for inclusion, discussions about who was selected became quite intense.
On Wednesday, Bradley announced his wildcard picks: Justin Thomas, Collin Morikawa, Ben Griffin, Cameron Young, Patrick Cantlay, and Sam Burns.
However, the question remains: Did he make the right choices?
Critics might argue against some selections, especially considering the major storyline of the year: Would Bradley opt to include himself?
OUT: Sam Burns
Although it was a challenging international setting, Sam Burns earned only one point from three matches during his Ryder Cup debut in Rome in 2023.
His inability to perform under pressure, demonstrated by his final round at the U.S. Open where he led after 54 holes but collapsed with a score of 78, poses a concern as such pressure is inevitable during the Ryder Cup.
IN: Keegan Bradley
Finishing 11th in the Ryder Cup standings, just above Burns in 16th, offers substantial reason for Bradley to select himself based on his performance.
Though balancing playing and captain duties would be complex, Bradley could have limited his matches to three, allowing him to focus on his game while relying on his vice-captains to oversee the others.
His previous achievements, including being one of the top point scorers in the 2012 home Ryder Cup, highlight that his absence as a player would be felt.
OUT: Patrick Cantlay
Ryder Cup captains value energy and personality to uplift the team, qualities that Patrick Cantlay lacks.
While he has shown resilience in the past, his slow play could become a liability, possibly even alienating fans if he struggles.
With a mediocre season placing him 15th in the final Ryder Cup standings, it’s arguable there were stronger candidates available.
IN: Maverick McNealy
Finishing five positions above Cantlay in rankings, McNealy would have injected fresh energy into the team as a cool-headed golfer and a solid performer.
Given his strong performance on the greens, he could have provided necessary support in pressure situations.
OUT: Collin Morikawa
Morikawa’s selection appears more based on reputation than current form.
His lackluster performance, with only one top 10 finish in his last 14 events and a low ranking in Strokes Gained: Putting, raises doubts about his inclusion.
IN: Brian Harman
In contrast, Harman concluded the season on a high note, with a top 10 finish at The Open and a stellar 63 at the Tour Championship.
His recent strong form and superior putting skills compared to Morikawa make a compelling argument for his selection.
