Derek Carr’s Retirement Causes Ripples in Saints’ Strategy
The primary focus in the NFL today revolves around the retirement of the Saints’ quarterback Derek Carr, previously of the Raiders. This unexpected decision has led to a flurry of inquiries about the team’s advance knowledge of Carr’s plans and the implications for their future.
Insights from Kellen Moore
During a media briefing, new head coach Kellen Moore shed light on the situation. According to Nick Underhill from NewOrleans.Football, Moore stated that Carr’s decision “came together recently.” Although the Saints sought clarity on Carr’s status before the draft, Moore emphasized that “the communication was great” throughout the process, as noted by ESPN’s Katherine Terrell.
Impact on Draft Strategy
Moore also indicated that the team’s understanding of Carr’s situation influenced their choice to draft Louisville quarterback Tyler Shough in the second round of the 2025 NFL Draft. This selection now adds Shough to a quarterbacks room that already includes two other players on rookie contracts. When questioned about the potential need for a veteran quarterback, Moore remarked that they would “certainly have awareness to it…if the opportunity presents itself,” as reported by John Hendrix of Athlon Sports.
Quarterback Competition
With no veteran quarterback currently on the roster, Moore affirmed that Shough, Spencer Rattler, and Jake Haener will have a chance to vie for the starting position. Shough, picked 40th overall, is now the highest-drafted quarterback for the Saints since Archie Manning was selected second overall in 1971.
Profiles of the Quarterbacks
Despite being a recent draft pick, Shough, at 25, is not the youngest member of the group; Rattler is 24, while Haener is 26. Shough transitioned from his initial stint at Oregon, where he sat behind Justin Herbert, to Texas Tech, where he started right away before transferring to Louisville. His record there included 23 touchdowns and 3,195 passing yards over the season.
Recent Experiences
Rattler started six games for the Saints last year, though the team struggled, losing all six. Haener, who missed his rookie season due to a suspension, had limited success during his only starting opportunity after Rattler’s initial stint. Meanwhile, Taysom Hill, once a starting quarterback, now participates at tight end but has limited passing attempts in recent years.
A Competitive Offseason Ahead
Ultimately, the upcoming offseason will see Shough, Rattler, and Haener competing fiercely for the starting quarterback role. Moore plans to rotate these players in first-team drills until one emerges as the clear choice.
