Two iconic science fiction series, Star Trek and Doctor Who, have been coexisting for decades, and excitingly, they are set to intersect more directly in 2025. Fans of both franchises recognize their numerous similarities: both originated in the 1960s, feature expansive lore and universes, and have devoted fans spanning generations. Their thematic parallels have led many to wonder if they could inhabit the same universe, raising the intriguing question of whether the paths of a Starfleet Captain and a certain eccentric time traveler might someday collide.
In a sneak peek for the Strange New Worlds Season 3 finale (via TVInsider), Anson Mount’s Captain Pike mentions the challenging months faced by the Enterprise. Pelia, portrayed by Carol Kane, retorts, “Challenging, schmallenging. Remind me to tell you about the time I spent with the time-traveling Doctor I once knew.” As a being who has lived for centuries, Pelia’s reference is a clear nod to the long-speculated connection between the two franchises, especially following an Easter egg featuring a TARDIS earlier in the season.
The History of Star Trek & Doctor Who’s Links
The notion of the Doctor on the Enterprise is not merely fan speculation. In 2005, during the reboot of Doctor Who under Russell T Davies, the idea of a crossover was seriously considered while Star Trek: Enterprise was still airing. Davies expressed his desire for the Doctor to challenge Starfleet’s seriousness with his unique personality. Although talks between BBC and Paramount about a crossover happened towards the end of Enterprise‘s run, the show’s cancellation halted any progress.
Despite long-standing frustrations among fans over missed opportunities for a crossover, occasional references have flared up over the years. In a 2024 episode of Doctor Who, Ncuti Gatwa’s Fifteenth Doctor casually mentions the potential of visiting the Enterprise crew, which reignited discussions on the crossover’s feasibility. The complexities of both universes suggest that while they share ideologies, their differing structures and timelines complicate any crossover narrative.
Could A Real Star Trek & Doctor Who Crossover Work?
At its core, the primary challenge of a crossover isn’t creativity but corporate interests. With Doctor Who under BBC and distributed by Disney+ while Star Trek is linked to Paramount, any genuine collaboration would necessitate an unprecedented legal agreement. Both Davies and Star Trek producer Alex Kurtzman recently showcased their enthusiasm for a crossover at San Diego Comic-Con 2024, hinting that the demand from fans might prompt studios to recognize the potential for merging these iconic franchises in an entertaining event.
With the growing trend of crossovers in streaming, this might be the perfect moment for a union of these beloved series. Although challenges in continuity and narrative integration exist, such a crossover could lead to significant cultural moments for both franchises. From witty exchanges with Spock to time machine lessons, the possibilities are boundless in a universe cozy with peculiarities and unexpected turns.
