Welcome to SI Golf’s Fact or Fiction

We’re thrilled to return to SI Golf’s Fact or Fiction, especially with the anticipated tee shots coming next Friday.

This time around, we’re ready to discuss a set of statements for writers and editors to label as either “Fact” or “Fiction,” accompanied by brief explanations. Occasionally, responses may also fall into the “Neutral” category due to the complexities within the world of golf.

Do you concur or dissent? Share your thoughts on SI Golf’s Twitter.

Expert Opinions

Bob Harig: FICTION. U.S. players have ample time to familiarize themselves with the course, with four days of practice planned for next week. Some might arrive earlier in the weekend. The focus should be on effectively utilizing this time, particularly in learning the greens and honing their putting skills.

Jeff Ritter: FICTION. While I appreciate the Euros’ innovative use of VR headsets, I believe both teams have equal preparation efforts. They’re doing all they can to arrive in New York well-prepared and in peak condition—it’s all a matter of strategy.

More Perspectives

John Pluym: FICTION. The Europeans’ approach suggests a lack of readiness for Bethpage. It’s questionable whether a quick two-day scouting trip will provide the necessary insights. Meanwhile, Keegan Bradley’s suggestion for his team to compete at the Procure Championship is commendable and a significant boost for the world’s top players.

John Schwarb: FACT. A scouting trip a week in advance is a sensible choice, even though its impact on the matches remains uncertain. The European team should focus on adjusting their body clocks. The U.S. team effectively gathered 10 of their 12 players for a Tour event, showing greater preparation compared to two years ago before Rome.

Final Thoughts

Bob Harig: FICTION. This strategy was previously adopted when the Ryder Cup coincided with the Tour Championship. One or two events should suffice to gauge form. Noren himself acknowledged that his timing was unfortunate.

John Schwarb: FACT. Why not consider continuing significant play after the teams’ marquee selection days? Perhaps the governing bodies should host a last-chance qualifier for the final team slots—many would tune in to watch.