Sam Burns Loses Championship Bid Amid Controversial USGA Ruling
Sam Burns was controversially denied relief in a pivotal moment at Oakmont
(Image: Andy Lyons/Getty Images)
Sam Burns faced a controversial ruling in the final stages of the U.S. Open, raising intense criticism from viewers, while J.J. Spaun celebrated a surprising win at Oakmont.
Burns entered the final round leading at three-under-par. However, faced with difficult conditions in Pittsburgh, he found it challenging to maintain his lead. By the time he reached the 15th tee, he shared the lead at one-over-par, but that is where his championship dreams began to fade.
After heavy rainfall caused nearly a two-hour delay, Burns’ tee shot on the 15th hole remained on the edge of the fairway, but the wet conditions created significant obstacles. Despite the greenskeepers’ efforts, standing water remained a problem on the course.
Burns asserted that he had an unplayable lie necessitating a drop, as water splashed during his practice swings. However, his request for relief was denied by two officials from the United States Golf Association (USGA).
Playing the shot subsequently resulted in a double bogey, eliminating him from contention, and he expressed his dissatisfaction with the USGA’s decision. The backlash intensified on social media after a reporter highlighted the waterlogged conditions affecting Burns’ shot, demonstrating how he was essentially hitting from a puddle.
Prominent figures, including ESPN’s Scott Van Pelt, joined the criticism, pointing out the absurdity of the ruling. Opinions on social media ranged from disbelief to outrage regarding the USGA’s treatment of Burns. Renowned golf coach Brian Manzella clarified that Burns should have received relief based on Rule 16.1 governing casual water.
Burns remained composed in his press conference, stating the fairway conditions were visibly wet and causing issues during practice swings. Despite seeking a second opinion from another rules official, he ultimately accepted their decision, noting that it was beyond his control.
Although Burns managed to birdie the 17th hole, his chances for U.S. Open glory slipped away as Spaun captured the title. Burns finished the tournament at three-over-par, while Bob MacIntyre claimed second place at one-over, with Viktor Hovland trailing by another shot.
