Uncertainty Surrounds Nationals Bullpen Heading into 2026
As the Washington Nationals approach the 2026 season, their bullpen remains filled with doubts. Last year, they recorded the worst bullpen ERA in Major League Baseball at 5.59. Instead of fortifying this unit, General Manager Paul Toboni has weakened it further by trading potential closer Jose A. Ferrer to the Mariners.
Anticipated Free Agent Additions
There is likely to be at least one free agent added to the bullpen this offseason, although most top options are already taken. Toboni’s apparent lack of urgency in pursuing free agent relievers suggests he has some confidence in the internal resources available.
Potential Bullpen Candidates
In light of this situation, let’s examine five pitchers who Toboni may find intriguing. While their past performances were not stellar, they possess compelling attributes that could be harnessed with some adjustments to their pitch usage.
Jackson Rutledge’s Future
First up is Jackson Rutledge, a former first-round pick whose 2025 season was disappointing, finishing with a 5.77 ERA across 63 appearances. However, he has potential pitch usage changes that could enhance his performance. Rutledge’s two most effective pitches—the slider and splitter—were underutilized last year.
Clayton Beeter’s Promising Performance
Another name to consider is Clayton Beeter. After being traded from the Yankees, he recorded a 2.49 ERA in 21.2 innings for the Nationals. Beeter currently relies on his slider 46% of the time, but switching to a heavier slider usage could yield even better results, as he has shown a strong ability to get swings and misses with it.
Orlando Ribalta’s Inconsistency
Orlando Ribalta, who struggled in 2025 with a 7.03 ERA, still possesses the talent to turn things around. Despite injuries, his impressive pitches—including a high-velocity four-seam fastball—indicate that he could become more effective. Improving his command and consistency will be crucial for his success moving forward.
New Addition: Griff McGarry
The Nationals recently selected Griff McGarry from the Phillies in the Rule 5 Draft. Previously a starter, he posted a 3.44 ERA in the minors, but his control issues may necessitate a shift to the bullpen. His exceptional raw talent makes him a fascinating prospect, contingent upon finding ways to improve his command.
Conclusion: Hope Amid Uncertainty
Finally, there’s Cole Henry, who managed to showcase his capabilities in 2025. While health remains a concern, his low slot and effective fastball give him the tools to contribute meaningfully. Although the bullpen has limited proven options, these emerging talents offer a glimmer of hope for improvement in 2026.
