The New York Giants are embarking on a new chapter with a Super Bowl-winning head coach and an exciting young roster. However, the 2025 season saw a disappointing outcome with only four victories, adding to the franchise’s struggles. Consequently, they hold the fifth overall pick in the upcoming 2026 NFL Draft, prompting John Harbaugh and Joe Schoen to focus on aligning their strategies and rejuvenating the team.
The Giants’ decisions at the fifth pick will be influenced by their free agency activities, targeting a potential “gold jacket” player, as indicated by Harbaugh. However, with a draft class perceived as less robust, it raises the question: can the Giants secure such a player? If they identify one, how significant will positional value be in Harbaugh and Schoen’s decision-making process?
The Giants are confronted with critical concerns on defense, particularly in the core of the unit. On the offensive side, acquiring an additional receiver may become a priority, even with Wan’Dale Robinson still in the fold, while the offensive line’s status remains uncertain based on Jermaine Eluemunor’s free agency situation. Below are four players who embody the potential “gold jacket” caliber.
Caleb Downs, S, Ohio State
Selecting a safety in the top five is rare; the last was Eric Berry in 2010, with Sean Taylor before him in 2004. Despite pressing needs elsewhere, the Giants invested significantly in their safety position with Jevon Holland and a second-round pick on Tyler Nubin in 2024. Yet, they’ve struggled to maximize their safety roles, especially after previous Giants, Xavier McKinney and Julian Love, found success elsewhere.
Caleb Downs stands out as a transformative player with the talent to disrupt offensive schemes. His range, instincts, and athleticism allow him to capitalize on late passes from quarterbacks, punishing offenses for mistakes. Additionally, he excels in run support, helping the defense manage lighter boxes effectively. Downs’ college career showcases 257 tackles, an impressive 16 tackles for loss, and several important defensive plays, making him a top contender in this draft class.
Rueben Bain Jr., Edge, Miami
The Giants require additional talent along the defensive line, and Bain Jr. is capable of excelling in both run defense and as a dynamic pass rusher. His versatility allows the defense to effectively manage front gaps, enhancing the Giants’ pass protection. As a standout at Miami, Bain Jr. logged significant pressure numbers, making him a candidate worth considering for the Giants as they enhance their defensive front.
Arvell Reese, LB, Ohio State
The Giants are in urgent need of speed in their linebacking corps. Reese, who enjoyed a brief yet impactful college career, showcased impressive stats during the 2025 season. His unique ability to move between linebacker and edge positions offers versatility for the Giants, and his explosiveness could provide crucial support in pressure situations.
Francis Mauigoa, OT, Miami
With right tackle Jermaine Eluemunor heading into free agency after two solid seasons, the Giants need to consider their options. Should he depart, they have limited choices at right tackle. Mauigoa, who excelled in college, providing robust protection and run-blocking, could be a viable option for the Giants to solidify their offensive line.
