Awards Predictions for the Guardians in 2026
CLEVELAND, Ohio — As the 2026 season approaches, a discussion on the latest Cleveland Baseball Talk Podcast explored potential awards for the Guardians, highlighting not just contenders but also the implications of these accolades on the team’s performance.
MVP Discussions Centered on José Ramírez
Podcast host Joe Noga emphasized that José Ramírez is the clear MVP candidate for the Guardians this season. His consistent high-level performance has positioned him as a perennial finalist, including a third-place finish in 2025. However, the podcast noted a significant need for another standout player to support Ramírez.
Searching for a Key Support Player
The team must find a second star to further their goals, according to the hosts. Noga noted, “For the Guardians to be serious contenders, they need someone to challenge and support Ramírez in driving in runs.” Potential candidates like Kyle Manzardo and C.J. Kayfus were discussed, but both are still developing and may not be ready for such a burden.
Rookie of the Year Candidate
Chase DeLauter emerged as a frontrunner for Rookie of the Year discussion, with his unique path to the majors further amplifying interest. Hoynes remarked, “He’s on the 40-man roster and will garner considerable attention during big league camp.”
Cy Young Contenders
The conversation shifted to potential Cy Young candidates, with Gavin Williams and Tanner Bibee both considered strong prospects. Hoynes noted Williams deserved recognition last season, while praising Bibee’s durability over his career.
Insight on Reliever of the Year
The discussion around MLB’s new Reliever of the Year award highlighted Cade Smith and Hunter Gaddis as the leading contenders, despite a larger focus potentially falling on closers. The hosts debated whether the award would accurately reflect the contributions of setup pitchers like Gaddis.
Understanding the Guardians’ Roster Construction
Overall, the award discussions provided a framework to comprehend the Guardians’ roster dynamics. While they possess elite talent like Ramírez and a promising pitching roster, a second offensive star remains missing. As Noga succinctly stated, “Batman needs his Robin.” This episode offers valuable analysis of the team’s strengths, weaknesses, and aspirations as they head into the 2026 season.
