This year features an unprecedented number of candidates for the Comeback Player of the Year Award, many of whom are also contenders for the Cy Young or MVP titles. Notable names include previous Cy Young winners like Jacob deGrom and Sandy Alcantara, alongside former MVPs such as Mike Trout and Ronald Acuña Jr. Last season, Chris Sale exemplified this dual achievement by winning both the National League comeback player award and the Cy Young.
The Comeback Player of the Year Award honors players in each league who triumphantly return to the field after setbacks. As we look toward 2025, here are 10 players to keep an eye on as they bounce back from significant injuries, alongside comments from their team executives and managers.
1. Sandy Alcantara, RHP, Marlins
After having a standout 2022 season where he won the NL Cy Young with a 2.28 ERA and 207 strikeouts over 228.2 innings, Alcantara missed the entirety of last season due to Tommy John surgery. This spring, he’s back and throwing up to 99 mph. At 29, he boasts a powerful changeup and slider, and if he can remain healthy, he’s a strong candidate for this award.
Peter Bendix, President of Baseball Operations for the Marlins: “Sandy looks strong and healthy — and he feels great!”
2. Shane McClanahan, LHP, Rays
Choosing between Alcantara and McClanahan for the top spot was tough, but Alcantara’s consistency slightly edged McClanahan out. The two-time All-Star was a Cy Young contender in 2022 but faced challenges in the second half of the season before undergoing Tommy John surgery. Now, at 27, he appears ready to excel again, showcasing a diligent offseason and a full revival of his pitching repertoire.
Kevin Cash, Rays manager: “The obvious highlight of our camp thus far is that Mac looks like Mac…”
3. Jacob deGrom, RHP, Rangers
With Hall of Fame potential, deGrom’s progress hinges on staying healthy. Since 2019, he’s failed to exceed 15 starts in a season. However, when fit, he has been a dominant force with multiple Cy Young awards to his name. After a second Tommy John surgery, he’s had a promising return this spring. The focus now is on maintaining his health and performance levels.
Chris Young, Rangers President of Baseball Operations: “He is one of the best pitchers in the world…”
4. Spencer Strider, RHP, Braves
Strider, who ranked fourth in the NL Cy Young voting, is making strides in his recovery from elbow surgery. Known for his fastball and breaking pitches, he had a remarkable all-star season in 2022. While he will not be on the Opening Day roster, expectations are high for his return later in the season.
Braves executive comments express optimism on Strider’s recovery and potential impact for the team.
5. Ronald Acuña Jr., RF, Braves
Acuña’s season-ending ACL injury in May following an exceptional 2023, where he became the first player to achieve the historic 40-70 mark, was devastating. As he works his way back to the field, the organization is prioritizing his health to ensure he can return to his peak performance.
Braves President of Baseball Operations: “We are anxious to get them back on the field.”
6. Mike Trout, RF, Angels
After several injury-plagued seasons, Trout is transitioning to a full-time right field role to preserve his health. At 34, he aims to regain his contributions as one of the league’s top players after sitting out much of last season. If he stays healthy, a return to All-Star form is very much on the horizon.
Angels GM: “Mike is in the best shape I’ve seen him in…”
7. Matt McLain, 2B, Reds
After a strong rookie season in 2023, McLain missed all of last season due to a shoulder injury, representing a significant addition to the Reds this year. His comeback could greatly enhance the team’s performance, and enthusiasm surrounding his return is high.
Reds executives shared their excitement about McLain’s potential impact this season.
8. Kodai Senga, RHP, Mets
Drawing considerable attention is Senga, who, if healthy, can transform the Mets’ pitching lineup significantly. After an impressive season in 2023, he faces recovery challenges but remains a key component for the Mets as they aim to compete.
Mets leadership expresses high hopes for Senga’s performance upon return.
9. Félix Bautista, RHP, Orioles
Bautista, distinguished for his standout closing performance in 2023, missed the entire last season post-surgery. His return could rejuvenate the Orioles’ bullpen, making him an asset to watch as he works his way back to the mound.
Orioles GM notes the excitement around Bautista’s training and anticipated return.
10. Christian Yelich, OF/DH, Brewers
After a strong start in the previous season, Yelich faced a significant back injury that led to surgery. Now aiming for a comeback at 33, he seeks to showcase his former MVP-level performance throughout 2025.
Brewer’s GM highlights the significance of Yelich’s return for the team’s prospects.
