Roy Keane Critiques Manchester United’s Coaching Changes
Roy Keane has voiced strong criticism of Manchester United’s newly established coaching team, engaging in a heated debate with Gary Neville. Michael Carrick has stepped in as the interim manager for the remainder of the season, taking over from Ruben Amorim. He has added former England assistant Steve Holland, ex-Middlesbrough assistant Jonathan Woodgate, retired player Jonny Evans, and Under-21s coach Travis Binnion to his team.
Keane expressed his dissatisfaction with the coaching staff selected by Carrick, dismissing the notion that Holland’s experience qualifies him as a so-called “guru.” He also questioned how Jonny Evans secured a prominent coaching role after recently leaving his position as United’s loans and pathways manager.
During an episode of the Stick to Football podcast, Neville stated that while Steve Holland may not guarantee success, he is a capable operator who enhances Carrick’s coaching staff. Keane quickly countered, asking about the credentials of the other coaches who have also been brought in. Neville admitted he was unfamiliar with the coaching abilities of Woodgate and Evans.
Keane highlighted the abrupt transition for Evans, who recently left a managerial role only to be given a coaching position with the first team. He questioned the rationale behind such a swift elevation in responsibility, emphasizing that it seems premature.
Neville attempted to clarify his views, indicating that Carrick needs to ensure his training sessions are of the highest quality given the pressure he faces. He expressed belief that Holland’s inclusion would ensure that standard. Keane, however, pointed out that while Holland may bring experience, it doesn’t necessarily equate to effective coaching, referencing previous staff who lacked success despite their credentials.
The conversation further delved into the hiring practices at United, with Keane questioning the merit of bringing in individuals with club ties, citing previous managerial hires that did not yield results. Neville defended such choices by noting that they can provide familiarity with the club’s culture.
In closing, Keane reiterated his concerns about Evans’ coaching qualifications, underlining that experience alone does not guarantee success, and he is skeptical about the overall effectiveness of Carrick’s newly formed staff.
