In a highly anticipated match in New York, Devin Haney secured a unanimous decision victory against Jose Ramirez on May 2nd. However, some analysts described the fight as lackluster, with boxing commentator Jim Lampley stating, “If ever there was a fight capable of inducing a nap in Times Square, it would be this one.” Veteran writer Dan Rafael echoed this sentiment, labeling the match “one of the worst fights I have seen in a long time.”
Former champion Timothy Bradley also voiced his dissatisfaction, criticizing Haney’s style by questioning, “Haney put on a s**t show… Did he train with Usain Bolt? Who the hell did he train with?” His remarks highlighted that the fight resembled a track competition more than a boxing match, reflecting a broader disappointment among fans and analysts alike.
These criticisms are further validated by CompuBox statistics, marking the Haney-Ramirez bout as one of only three 12-round fights with the lowest total punches landed in over 40 years. Haney connected on just 70 of 224 attempts, while Ramirez had an even lower rate, landing 40 of 279. Remarkably, the fight peaked with Haney landing only nine punches in the ninth round, emphasizing the lack of action.
Amidst the negativity, Claressa Shields, one of the best female boxers, offered a unique perspective. When asked whether Haney’s performance was boxing or merely “running,” she stated, “It was boxing, but I think it was too much boxing.” She emphasized that boxing is about engagement, noting that while she was glad to see Haney back, she expects more from him.
Shields recognized Haney’s efficiency—landing punches at a 31.3% rate compared to Ramirez’s 14.3%. However, she stressed that boxing isn’t only a strategic game; it’s a dynamic combat sport. She believes Haney has further potential that he should harness, especially as he looks ahead to a possible rematch with Ryan Garcia.
Caleb Plant weighed in, asserting that the style Haney employed was deliberate rather than a sign of anxiety, stating, “He clearly trained to fight like that. So that was purposeful.” He highlighted the discipline needed for such a performance and noted that implying laziness or fear overlooks the craft involved in Haney’s approach.
Ultimately, while Haney’s fight against Ramirez may not have excited fans, Plant emphasized that winning—rather than entertainment—remains the primary objective in boxing. He critiqued the unfair burden placed on boxers to be entertaining, reminding viewers that Haney executed the strategy he prepared for, showcasing his skill and intelligence in the ring.
Dutch
English
French
German
Italian
Korean
Portuguese
Spanish