ESPN NFL analyst Seth Walder has rated the New York Giants offseason efforts as a “B” grade.
So, what led Walder to this assessment? Here’s a summary of his points:
The Giants entered the offseason looking for a quarterback, and they ended up acquiring three. They signed both Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston through free agency, utilizing a combined $14 million in cap space, which Walder viewed as a smart financial move.
At the outset, there was uncertainty regarding their ability to draft a top-tier QB. Wilson enhances the team’s baseline performance while Winston potentially maximizes their ceiling. Although neither player is expected to be the long-term solution, trying both at that price is justified.
The key investment came during the draft when the Giants traded back into the first round to select Jaxson Dart at No. 25, following their selection of edge rusher Abdul Carter at No. 3. In this move, the Giants transferred the Texans’ No. 99 pick and a third-round selection in 2026.
This was a calculated risk that could pay off; while Dart may not succeed, the Giants positioned themselves to seek out a franchise quarterback.
The most significant free agent signing was Paulson Adebo, a choice Walder was skeptical about. Despite Adebo having impressive numbers over the past two seasons, he had a broken femur last year, raising concerns about his stability as a performer in subsequent years.
Contrasting with Adebo, the other major secondary signing, safety Jevon Holland, was seen more favorably. The Giants secured Holland at $15 million per year, which is comparable to Camryn Bynum’s deal and less than Tre’von Moehrig’s, making it a smart addition given his reputation as one of the top safeties available.
The Giants also chose to re-sign receiver Darius Slayton at $12 million per year, which Walder views as a reasonable decision, emphasizing the team’s need for outside receiving talent.
Valentine’s Perspective
Previously, I indicated that the Giants should be recognized as offseason winners, even if showcasing that becomes challenging due to their schedule.
Walder’s analysis hasn’t changed my stance on this.
Much of what I noted in June remains pertinent:
My position-by-position evaluation suggests the Giants may have improved across every role.
On the defensive side, they integrated impactful talent in Abdul Carter, Paulson Adebo, and Jevon Holland, while also adding depth in the front seven.
I concur with Walder’s assessment of the quarterback situation. While Wilson and Winston aren’t flawless solutions, they elevate the expected performance for the Giants. Additionally, Dart introduces a sense of optimism about the future at that critical position.
I differ with Walder’s view on Adebo; I see that signing as a positive move.
It was clear that the Giants needed to invest in securing a top-tier cornerback. Adebo, at 26, has the potential to grow, making this signing appropriate as the Giants aim for both immediate and long-term success.
How do you assess Walder’s offseason rating for the Giants? Is it too generous, too harsh, or just about right?
