MLB Cy Young Race Takes Shape
As the 2025 MLB season progresses, the Cy Young races for both leagues are starting to take clarity. At this point in the season, with approximately eight or nine starts for most starting pitchers and 15 or more appearances for many relievers, early achievements can no longer be dismissed as mere luck or a temporary hot streak. It’s the right moment to seriously consider the results.
Expert Opinions on Cy Young Contenders
MLB.com’s initial Cy Young poll of the season highlights the impressive pitching talent across the American League (AL) and National League (NL). We surveyed 37 experts to gauge their predictions for the eventual Cy Young winners in both leagues, factoring in current performances as well as anticipated outcomes.
Poll Results Overview
In total, 35 pitchers received votes, with 17 from the AL and 18 from the NL. Voters were asked to rank their top five choices in each league, assigning points on a 5-4-3-2-1 basis. The following includes the results up to this point, accounting for statistics through Sunday.
Top Pitchers in the AL
Tarik Skubal, although not as overpowering as in 2024 when he secured the pitching Triple Crown and a unanimous AL Cy Young Award, remains a strong contender. With a 2.08 ERA and remarkable stats such as 60 strikeouts and a WHIP of 0.88, his performance keeps him in the limelight.
Max Fried has excelled for the Yankees with a perfect 6-0 record and an impressive 1.05 ERA, showcasing why the team invested heavily in him. He has allowed only six earned runs this season, contributing to the Yankees’ 8-0 record in games he started.
Resurgent Performers
Hunter Brown has been a noteworthy addition for the Astros this season, tying for the MLB lead with six wins and quality starts while sporting a stellar 1.86 FIP and 1.48 ERA. Additionally, Nathan Eovaldi, in his 14th MLB season, boasts a 1.78 ERA and currently leads the league in WHIP with 0.75, marking some of the best performances of his career.
Top Pitchers in the NL
Yoshinobu has lived up to expectations with a league-leading 1.80 ERA and an impressive .188 average against. His exceptional split-finger fastball has contributed significantly to his success. Paul Skenes, last season’s NL Rookie of the Year, still shows promise despite slightly lower stats this season, while Logan Webb is enjoying a noteworthy performance with a 2.60 ERA and 65 strikeouts.
Pursuing Excellence
Hunter Greene continues to demonstrate his All-Star potential, and Zack Wheeler leads the league in innings pitched, reinforcing his reputation as a consistent performer. Both pitchers showcase the depth and talent present in this season’s medalists as we progress towards the mid-season mark.
Conclusion
The Cy Young race is shaping up to be highly competitive based on current performances and expert predictions. With significant contributions from various pitchers, fans can anticipate an exciting continuation of the season as these athletes strive for excellence.
