As each season unfolds, factors like injuries, slumps, and breakout performances can alter the batting order and sometimes spotlight new standout players.
The 2025 season has been no different, with several unexpected players stepping up as top hitters. In many instances, these players have emerged as their teams’ most effective offensive contributors.
With Memorial Day on the horizon, here are ten surprising athletes who currently top their teams in hitting.
The rankings are based on wRC+—a statistic that evaluates a hitter’s offensive output in terms of run production while making adjustments for league and park influences (a wRC+ of 100 is average)—among players with at least 120 plate appearances this season. All statistics are as of Thursday.
Harrison Bader, OF, Twins
Primarily recognized for his defensive skills, Bader has shown a more rounded performance in 2025. After 39 games, the 30-year-old has a batting average of .300, with four home runs and a 146 wRC+. His leading position in Minnesota’s batting stats highlights the team’s overall offensive struggles this year.
Rhys Hoskins, 1B, Brewers
Questions surrounded Hoskins’ future entering 2025 after missing all of 2023 due to a torn ACL. However, he seems rejuvenated this season, hitting .292 with a 140 wRC+. His offensive contributions have been crucial for the Brewers, especially while other star players have underperformed.
Ryan O’Hearn, DH, Orioles
Despite Baltimore’s disappointing 15-27 record, O’Hearn has stepped up as a surprise hitter in a mixed role, boasting a .295 average with seven home runs and a stellar 159 wRC+. His performance has been vital as several key players strive to find their rhythm.
Jeremy Peña, SS, Astros
After a remarkable rookie year in 2022, Peña struggled in subsequent seasons, but he appears ready to reclaim his star potential in 2025. With a .313 average and a 137 wRC+, he has helped stabilize Houston’s offense amid challenges faced by other team veterans.
Josh Smith, UTIL, Rangers
Smith’s versatility has made him indispensable to the Rangers’ lineup, as he has played nearly every position. Alongside his defensive contributions, he is excelling offensively with a .306 average and a 139 wRC+, making a significant impact during a challenging season for the team.
Masyn Winn, SS, Cardinals
Since Winn’s return from injury, the Cardinals have experienced a turnaround, going 15-6 in their last 21 games. With a .319 average and a 137 wRC+, his performance has markedly improved from his rookie season, providing both offensive and defensive value to the team.
Jacob Wilson, SS, Athletics
Wilson’s impressive batting skills have drawn comparisons to past champions, contributing to the A’s strong start. Currently, he boasts a .347 batting average with a 149 wRC+, solidifying his position as a key player in improving the team’s offensive output.
