Each spring, players who faced disappointing seasons express hopes for a comeback. However, most fail to achieve this because overcoming setbacks is challenging.
Sometimes, changes in technique or new strategies don’t yield results. Additionally, being in peak physical condition doesn’t always lead to optimal performance metrics.
Yet, there are instances when, by mid-May, these ambitions start to materialize. This article focuses on such players—those with past achievements who fell short in 2025 but are seizing new opportunities this season.
Despite some early success, it’s too early to declare “Mission accomplished” as a significant portion of the season is still ahead. Therefore, we consulted a team of MLB.com writers and analysts to highlight 10 notable rebounders who were below league average in 2025, examining their path to renewed success and its sustainability.
To make this list, hitters must have had a minimum of 350 plate appearances in 2025 and 100 in ’26, while pitchers need at least 100 innings in 2025 and 30 in ’26. We used OPS+ for hitters and ERA+ for pitchers to measure each player’s rebound, both of which are scaled against an MLB average of 100. All statistics are through Friday’s games.
Nolan Arenado, 3B, D-backs
2025 OPS+: 89 | 2026 OPS+: 128 (+39 points)
Arenado has seen a decline in his exit velocity since 2023, leading to diminished offensive production. Although his overall numbers appear improved this year, his exit velocity has reached a new low. The dramatic drop since 2023 has played a big role in his struggles. While moving to Chase Field has improved his hitting stats significantly, it remains unclear if this change alone accounts for his rebound.
Dylan Cease, RHP, Blue Jays
2025 ERA+: 93 | 2026 ERA+: 181 (+88 points)
Cease’s initial season with the Blue Jays appeared subpar with a 4.55 ERA, yet his underlying metrics suggested he deserved better. This season, he has notably decreased his barrel rate and is on track for his sixth consecutive 200-strikeout season. His resurgence as a dominant pitcher proves his transition back to ace form.
Oneil Cruz, CF, Pirates
2025 OPS+: 86 | 2026 OPS+: 125 (+39 points)
Cruz has excelled at hitting the ball hard. While luck has played a role in his current success—with a high batting average on balls in play—he’s also adjusted his approach by pulling the ball more and improving against breaking pitches. This strategic shift is contributing to his renewed effectiveness at the plate.
Bryce Elder, RHP, Braves
2025 ERA+: 78 | 2026 ERA+: 219 (+141 points)
Elder’s career reflects a cyclical path, moving from being an All-Star to struggling, then back to strong form. After refining his pitches with a Hall of Famer, he’s shown remarkable improvement, becoming a reliable starter for the Braves and contributing to their leading ERA in MLB.
Michael Harris II, CF, Braves
2025 OPS+: 88 | 2026 OPS+: 138 (+50 points)
Harris had a mixed 2025 season, but a strong finish has fueled his performance in 2026. He’s noticeably improved his exit velocity and hard-hit rate, showcasing a more effective offensive game. His strategic adjustments and increased walk rate have led to a promising season so far.
George Kirby, RHP, Mariners
2025 ERA+: 91 | 2026 ERA+: 137 (+46 points)
While Kirby’s strikeout rates have dipped, he’s been effective by focusing more on preventing quality contact. His improved expected ERA suggests a shift in his performance trajectory, indicating he is likely to rebound effectively this season.
Conclusion
Various players are showcasing their potential to rebound after underwhelming seasons, each taking unique paths to achieve renewed success. Whether through adjustments, improved stats, or changes in conditions, their performances deserve monitoring as the season progresses.
